Profitability and financial modelling
Why a sold-out prize draw can still lose money
Selling every ticket feels like proof a draw worked. It isn’t. If the prize, the price and the entry cap were set without the full cost list, a draw can sell out and still finish in the red.
The problem
Most competition sites judge a draw by one number: tickets sold against the cap. The costs that decide whether it made money sit elsewhere: in the card processor’s statement, the VAT return, the free postal entries and the ad account. None of them show up on the progress bar.
Since HMRC wrote to prize-draw businesses in July 2026 restating its view that paid entries are standard-rated for VAT, operators who weren’t accounting for VAT have to build it in, and the gap gets wider. A draw that used to clear a thin margin can now lose money at 100% sold.
A worked example
Hypothetical figures The operator, draw and numbers below are invented to show the mechanics. They are not any real business.
- Prize: a car costing £30,000 delivered. Assume the operator can’t reclaim VAT on it.
- Entry price £1.99, capped at 19,999 entries. The draw sells out.
- 5% of entries come through the free postal route, so 18,999 are paid.
- Card fees at Stripe’s standard UK rate, 1.5% + 20p per payment, as a benchmark; your processor may charge more. Players buy 3 entries per payment on average.
- Marketing £4,000. Website and draw platform £800.
| Sold out, 18,999 paid entries | Before VAT | With 20% VAT on paid entries |
|---|---|---|
| Ticket sales | £37,808 | £37,808 |
| VAT (one sixth of paid sales) | £0 | −£6,301 |
| Prize | −£30,000 | −£30,000 |
| Card fees | −£1,834 | −£1,834 |
| Marketing and platform | −£4,800 | −£4,800 |
| Result | £1,174 | −£5,127 |
| Paid entries needed to break even | 18,379 | 22,282 |
Where the money went
VAT takes one sixth of the price. If the price includes VAT, £1 in every £6 goes to HMRC. On this draw that’s £6,301, more than the whole margin before VAT.
The fixed card fee bites on small baskets. 20p on a single £1.99 entry is 10% of the price; on a 3-entry basket it’s 3.4%. At 3 entries per payment, fees total £1,834, nearly 5% of sales. If players bought 6 entries at a time, fees would drop to about £1,200.
Free entries take capped places. Every free postal entry uses one of the 19,999 places, brings no money in, and has the same chance of winning. Here, 1,000 free entries cost £1,990 of possible ticket sales, before VAT and fees.
The prize was set first. A sell-out at £1.99 brings in at most £39,798. A £30,000 car leaves £9,798 for everything else, before free entries, fees and VAT take their share.
What would have changed the result
Both changes below are made before launch. If you follow the DCMS voluntary code, a live draw’s prize and end date shouldn’t change because sales are low.
| Change before launch (VAT case, sold out) | Result | Break-even paid entries (% of the 18,999 paid places) |
|---|---|---|
| As planned | −£5,127 | 22,282 (117%) |
| Prize £25,000 instead of £30,000 | −£127 | 19,081 (100.4%) |
| Price £2.49, same entries sold (untested) | £2,647 | 17,657 (93%) |
A £25,000 prize alone isn’t enough: the draw still loses about £127 at sell-out. It needs combining with a smaller free-entry share, a higher price or a lower cost base. The £2.49 row assumes the draw still sells out at a higher price. That’s an assumption to test, not a given.
My recommendation
Before any draw goes live, work out its break-even as a share of the places that can actually be paid for (the cap minus expected free entries), with VAT in. If break-even is above 100%, the draw can’t make money however well it sells. If it’s close to 100%, one slow week turns it into a loss. Set the prize, the price and the cap so break-even sits comfortably below sell-out, and check the card-fee and free-entry assumptions against your last few draws, not against hope.
Your next step
- Run your own numbersFree prize-draw margin calculatorFree
- Model your draw in ExcelPrize-Draw Profitability Model: break-even, sell-through from 25% to 100%, three VAT scenarios£49
- Get your numbers ready for a buyerSale-Readiness Review: profit by draw, VAT scenarios, cash against prize liabilities, buyer Q&A pack£1,950
Sources
- HMRC “One to Many” letters on VAT and prize draws, July 2026, as reported by ICAEW, August 2026.
- DCMS, Voluntary Code of Good Practice for Prize Draw Operators, clauses 2.2 and 2.5 (page updated 19 October 2026).
- City AM on the Omaze VAT appeal at the First-tier Tribunal, October 2026.
- Stripe, UK pricing: standard UK cards 1.5% + 20p, checked 7 November 2026. Premium and non-UK cards cost more.
General information, not legal or tax advice. A prize-draw operator (Omaze) has challenged HMRC’s view at the First-tier Tribunal; a decision is expected in spring 2027. Check your own position with a VAT adviser.